他們被制度謀殺了，機組只是不自覺的工具人而已，我們要探究的是，如何揪出元凶
作者 / forexkan
首先，我必須說很高興終於有司法單位主動介入，調查民航這塊爛瘡疤，但是因為國家考試不考民航法規，而民航法牽涉到很多技術性的概念，純粹由普通刑法來評價確實有些難度。這些民航從業人員違法犯紀，其危害程度不亞於頂新集團的造假；頂新集團是針對全民全面性慢性投毒，航空公司為了績效而違法造假的行為，不啻如針對全民隨機埋入的定時炸彈。
（參考新聞：四秒關引擎 資深機師質疑違反程序）
航空公司機務部門為了圖利公司討好長官，粉飾自己績效，不按規定執行檢修程序，卻在業務文書上登載不實，歷年來就算被民航局查獲，民航也只是行政罰鍰，從來沒有移送，這些被查獲的都是民航局事後稽核查出來的，只是冰山的一角，還有更多等著引爆下一次空難。
正如此次復興空難，顯然機組在第一個發動機失效後，執行程序時關錯發動機，為何一個訓練有素的機長會犯下如此重大且明顯的錯誤？這應該可以證實在他起飛前一定有某些因素困擾他，這印證媒體登載，有人爆料機長提及在前一段航行中發動機異常，機務要他這趟飛回來再修；這種事對機長來說往往造成很大壓力，明知不可為而為之，但若不為，後果也可能造成他個人遭公司秋後算帳，所以可以推導帶著這種預先知道發動機異常的忐忑情境跟壓力，在飛機一起飛時竟然真的發生發動機失效情事，錯愕、慌亂可見一斑。
這可以由機長向塔台發出Mayday求救，是在兩個發動機都失效才發出的就可以證實，因為全世界的機師所受的訓練從入門第一課到退休，是每半年必考科目，而單發失效原則程序都是1.先穩住飛機、2.保持航向、3.上高度避地障，接著呼救，再來才是執行將故障發動機關油門、關電門；因此先前發動機異常的先佔情境，應該是造成他錯愕慌亂的主因，進而導致關錯發動機，而且可能三名駕駛都同樣陷於因為先前發動機異常，機務又不願檢修的陰影，這都必須揉入人性因素(Human Factor, 我不認同用人為因素，ICAO手冊的解釋就是人性)考量，才能最終判斷當時的情境。
事後批評人家時，要設身處地(put yourself into their shoes)，想像一下人家當時的情境，不要一開始造神造成這樣，現在又落井下石，太不堪了，固然他們害人害己不應該，但是失速警告stall stall 響了五次，可以判斷他們在最後還是在失速邊緣勉強保持高度，無論是想撐回機場或找落地點，這都是出於拯救生命的善念，他們被制度謀殺了，機組只是不自覺的工具人而已，我們要探究的是，如何揪出元凶，把這幫真正的罪魁禍首杜絕掉。我期待士檢能有所作為。
(作者擔任過國內航空公司機師，經作者授權刊登)
延伸閱讀：不該發生的空難 – 機師憶空難調查報告、復興航空空難 機師現身說法
![[轉] 「芒果乾」與「正義感」](http://newcongress.tw/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/馬英九指蔡英文操弄「亡國感」.jpg)
appreciate the effort keep it up
nice website
グッチ 香水 新作 メンズ
アディダス ヨガ バッグ
Glad to be 1 of many visitants on this awful web website : D.
グッチ サングラス 赤 tシャツ
デュベティカ vega ジャパン
サマンサタバサ プチチョイス 大阪
エルメス プレゼント 60代
アディダス ハイカット 緑
adidas リュック
エルメス プレゼント 60代
マークジェイコブス おしゃれ zippo
デュベティカ 青山 在庫
ミュウミュウ フランス 値段
Conveyancing
オロビアンコ マフラー 評価
ナイキ 腕時計 楽天
It
Superb post but I was wanting to know in the event you could write a litte far more on this topic? I
マイケルコース 時計 取り扱い店 大阪
バーバリー コート メンズ グレー
Outstanding read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was performing a bit research on that. And he truly bought me lunch as I identified it for him smile So let me rephrase that: Thank you for lunch!
This really is a appropriate weblog for would like to find out about this subject. You realize a lot its almost challenging to argue along (not that I personally would want
ニューバランス 996 レザー 576
miumiu 財布 岡山
プラダ カードケース 楽天
paul smith 型落ち 販売
ナイキ シューズ
マイケルコース メンズ 財布 ganzo
アグ ブーツ バーゲン
フルラ 綿毛布 ダブル
オークリー 限定 キャディバッグ
フェリージ 京都
フェンディ ネクタイ 評判
バーバリー トレンチコート 真冬
フェンディ ネクタイ 評判
バーバリー トレンチコート 真冬
I dugg some of you post as I thought they were very beneficial invaluable
Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and adore learning a lot more on this subject. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with a lot more details? It is very beneficial for me.
フェリージ グローブ vip
amazon ニューバランス ベビー
フェリージ カードケース 通販 激安
ニューバランス シューズ 649
ニューバランス グレー 24.5
ニューバランス 新作 abc
ジェイコブス グアム opi
クロムハーツ メガネ インボイス
フェリージ 888 アパート
ロエベ 革 バッグ 汚れ
エルメス 財布 メンズ ベルルッティ
フェンディ バッグ チャーム bar
coach ベルト
ボッテガヴェネタ キャンバス バッグ
This web page might be a walk-through like the data you wanted concerning this and didn
フェリージ ポイント tポイント
キップリング 詩 英語
サマンサタバサ cm 三代目 画像 最新
オークリー カスタム 原宿
クロムハーツ 店舗 品揃え
This internet site may possibly be a walk-through its the data you wanted in regards to this and didn
miumiu バッグ 赤 nゲージ
duvetica ダウン 寒い
プラダ 偽物 タグ
オロビアンコ 時計 口コミ lava
デュベティカ ダウン 神戸
グッチ スニーカー サイズ 大きめ
グッチ ネクタイ ランキング 9月
トリーバーチ 靴 コーデ mery
ウェディングドレス ベルト
グッチ サングラス バタフライ
フルラ お財布
コーチ レザー 財布
ナイキ エアマックス90 中古
楽天 フェリージ ポーチ
アディダス パーカー カップル
ルイヴィトン メンズ ローファー
フルラ パイパー 新色
Just what I was seeking for, appreciate it for posting .
your weblog is really very good. It was extremely nicely authored and effortless to understand. Unlike additional blogs I’ve read which are truly not good. I also found your posts very intriguing
Some truly marvellous function on behalf with the owner of this internet internet site , perfectly excellent content .
トリーバーチ 店舗 グアム
ヴィトン ネクタイ 公式 mp3
ケイトスペード ポーチ ゴールド
ugg 靴
chanel パウダー
mcm ダウンジャケット
オロビアンコ ペンケース 梅田
キプリング 免税店 vipカード
マークジェイコブス チーク nars
エルメス ベルト 安い
ゴヤール バッグ ピンク dvd
ゴヤール バッグ 価格 com
I totally realize what you’ve explained. In fact, I browsed throughout your several other content material articles and I do believe you’re definitely correct. Congrats with this particular blog.
Glad to be one of many visitants on this awing internet web site : D.
コーチ バッグ 人気 色
コーチ 財布 修理 金額
フルラ メトロポリス 意味
モンクレール ダウンコート 2013
ティンバーランド ブーツ 通販
サマンサタバサ 財布 値段
フルラ って ファイル
ugg 二子玉川
ボッテガヴェネタ 財布 ネイビー
ミュウミュウ 財布 10000
ミュウミュウ 大宮 0760
サマンサタバサ キーケース 新作 bgm
フェリージ 修理 resh
ティンバーランド チノパン コーデ
Excellent post, thank you a whole lot for sharing. Do you might have an RSS feed I can subscribe to?
マイケルコース 財布 リボン ピンク
デュベティカ お手入れ
ボッテガヴェネタ ボディバッグ 40代
ティンバーランド 6インチブーツ メンズ
ティンバーランド 7.5w
ティンバーランド 7.5w
You will find some fascinating points in time in this posting but I don
ティンバーランド おしゃれ vip
バーバリー ベビー服 80 50
burberry 福袋 3000円
クロエ 財布 新作 メンズ
マイケルコース 表参道
gucci 香水 販売店
adidas cm 曲 2014
I just wanted to let you know how much my partner and i appreciate anything you
デュベティカ ショートダウン レディース
timberland 意味
プラダ キーケース ナイロン
ポールスミス 女 80キロ
フェンディ 時計 新品 傷
you’re in point of fact a excellent webmaster. The web internet site loading pace is incredible. It seems which you are doing any unique trick. Also, The contents are masterpiece. you
ルイヴィトン 手帳 オークション
オロビアンコ ボディバッグ 値段
ロエベ ナッパアイレ 激安 6畳
クロエ モレッツ スターウォーズ
クロエ 時計 楽天
ugg エンジニアブーツ
サマンサタバサ cm ソング 三代目 歌詞
アディダス デュラモ 評価
トリーバーチ フラットシューズ 色
Wow! This could be one certain with the most helpful blogs We
It can be tough to write about this topic. I believe you did an excellent job though! Thanks for this!
I conceive this internet web site contains some rattling fantastic information for everybody : D.
Some genuinely rattling work on behalf of the owner of this site , utterly wonderful content material material .
You ought to join in a contest for starters of the highest quality blogs online. I will recommend this page!
シャネル 財布 赤 価格
I believe this web web site has some rattling amazing information for every person : D.
Hey! This is kind of off subject but I want some advice from an established weblog. Is it difficult to set up your personal weblog? I
マークジェイコブス 青山 駄々(ダダ)
ポールスミス 愛知県 イケヤ
トリーバーチ 靴 メタリック 違い
シャネル 香水 プラチナム
マイケルコース 公式 時計
Wow, superb weblog structure! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging glance simple. The total appear of your web internet site is excellent, neatly as the content material material!
アグ ジャパン cm
コンバース タクティカル
Good read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was performing just a little research on that. And he just bought me lunch since I found it for him smile So let me rephrase that: Thank you for lunch!
I conceive you have noted some extremely interesting details , appreciate it for the post.
Nowhere on the Internet is there this considerably quality and clear information on this subject. How do I know? I know because I
ロエベ 財布 バッグ uシリーズ
サマンサタバサ レディアゼル 激安
エルメス メンズ クラッチバッグ
burberry 時計 調整
burberry 時計 調整
エルメス メンズ クラッチバッグ
I agree completely with what you said. Fantastic Stuff. Keep it going..
mcm exo カタログ rom
ロエベ ショルダー 歌
コーチ 9953
ポールスミス 時計 セイコー
Can I say that of a relief to locate somebody that in fact knows what theyre talking about over the internet. You definitely know how to bring a challenge to light and produce it essential. The diet ought to have a look at this and recognize why side within the story. I cant believe youre not a lot more well-liked when you completely offer the gift.
Outstanding post, I believe weblog owners should larn a lot from this website its rattling user friendly .
プラダ バッグ ピンク 2012
I agree together with your points , fantastic post.
グッチ ギルティ クリーム
ブルガリ エルゴン バンド
シャネル 歌
ティンバーランド レディース 知恵袋 rss
ティンバーランド レディース 知恵袋 rss
シャネル デニム生地 バッグ
I had been honored to obtain a call from a friend as he found the crucial guidelines shared on the internet site. Browsing your weblog post can be a real amazing experience. Thanks again for thinking of readers like me, and I hope for you the most effective of achievements as being a professional discipline.
Some truly good stuff on this site, I really like it.
オークリー ゴルフ ポロシャツ tシャツ
Does your web site have a contact page? I
After study several of the content inside your internet website now, and I actually such as your indicates of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark web site list and will also be checking back soon. Pls appear into my internet page likewise and tell me what you feel.
You need to join in a contest very first with the greatest blogs on the web. I will recommend this web website!
Numerous thanks for spending some time to write about this, I actually feel clearly about it and I really like to researching far much more about this concern. Whenever possible, would you mind updating your weblog with a whole lot far more information? It is quite beneficial for me.
Hiya! Amazing blog! I happen to be a every day visitor to your web site (somewhat far more like addict ) of this website. Just wanted to say I appreciate your blogs and am seeking forward for a lot more!
フェンディ ハンカチ amazon
コーチ ビジネスバッグ ブラウン
This is a great common sense post. Quite helpful to 1 who is just locating the resouces about this part. It will definitely support educate me.
ブルガリ ネックレス 125周年
ナイキ ダンク ハイ ホワイト
ナイキ ハイカット 青
シャネル 財布 a50097
ミュウミュウ 靴 ビジュー
トリーバーチ 折財布
adidas スニーカー 図鑑
クロエ リリー ゴールド
ナイキ エアフォース 2014
I genuinely like your writing style, excellent information, appreciate it for posting : D.
I completely agree with you about this matter. Nice post. Already bookmarked for future reference.
フェリージ リュックサック
デュベティカ 青山 web予約
ボッテガヴェネタ 大黒屋 チケット
I
I?
You will find quite lots of details that way to consider. That is actually a great examine bring up. I supply thoughts above as general inspiration but clearly you’ll be able to locate questions just like the 1 you retrieve the spot that the most significant factor will likely be in the honest excellent faith. I don?t know if guidelines have emerged about issues like that, but Almost surely that your chosen job is clearly labeled as a reasonable game. Both youngsters notice the impact of just a little moment
Hmm is anyone else encountering issues with the pictures on this blog loading? I
アグ モカシン 靴下 copo
ヴィトン メンズ 財布 黒
アグ モカシン 靴下 copo
ヴィトン 財布 偽物 画像
ヴィトン メンズ 財布 黒
アグ モカシン 靴下 copo
アグ モカシン 靴下 copo
ヴィトン 財布 偽物 画像
ロエベ 名古屋三越
ウェディングドレス 購入 仙台 9月
ポールスミス 大名 awキッチン
エルメス 大阪 品揃え
エルメス 財布 ふたつおり
エルメス ピコタン 免税店 sk2
エルメス 大阪 品揃え
エルメス ピコタン 免税店 sk2
エルメス 財布 ふたつおり
セリーヌ カバ 色
エルメス クリッパー 評価
ニューバランス 574 モノクローム
コンバース usaモデル
デュベティカ ベスト メンズ ポケット
ニューバランス 574 モノクローム
エルメス デニム メンズ ブランド
コンバース インヒール スキニー
As I website owner I believe the content material material here is quite superb, thanks for your efforts.
I certainly did not realize that. Learnt something new right now! Thanks for that.
I genuinely enjoyed this. It was incredibly educational and beneficial. I will return to examine on upcoming posts
My oh my appears as if your blog O
Do you wear boxers or biefs? I wana bui em.
Oh my goodness! an remarkable post dude. Thank you Even so My business is experiencing problem with ur rss . Don
Thank you for your details and respond to you. auto loans westvirginia
Someone essentially lend a hand to make critically articles I
You’ve got noted quite interesting points ! ps nice site .
I have been absent for a even though, but now I remember why I used to enjoy this blog. Thanks , I
Immediately a bit of guests will continue across hotel rooms and obtain tied bus excursions, nonetheless, a lot of with all the fancy car applications provide your personal tour specialist. That just may assist you browse via the neighborhood effectively you could an individual
Hey there! Good stuff, please keep me posted when you post something like this!
But wanna admit that this really is really valuable , Thanks for taking your time to write this.
I am glad that I discovered this website , exactly the right info that I was searching for! .
Aw, it was a really great post. In notion I would like to devote writing such as this furthermore,??iC spending time and specific work to produce a great write-up?- nonetheless so what can I say?- I waste time alot and never at all seem to obtain one thing completed.
I would like to thnkx for the efforts you have put in writing this blog. I
I feel 1 of your advertisements triggered my internet browser to resize, you may want to put that on your blacklist.
This can indicate that a watch has spent some or all of its life in the tropics and was not serviced as regularly as it need to have been.
Hello
Thanks for this great. I’m wondering if you were preparing of publishing comparable articles to this 1. .Maintain up the outstanding posts!
Some genuinely great weblog posts on this internet web site , regards for contribution.
This web-site can be a walk-through rather than the information you wished about it and didn
Regards for this post, I am a big big fan of this site would like to go on updated.
I am typically to blogging and i genuinely appreciate your posts. The content material has truly peaks my interest. Let me bookmark your web internet site and sustain checking for brand spanking new info.
Hello blogger. I like your blog about Tales from abroad
Significant other, this excellent website is fabolous, i merely adore it
Deference to op , some superb selective data .
I just added this webpage to my feed reader, great stuff. Cannot get enough!
amazing post, really informative. I wonder why the other experts of this sector do not notice this. You need to continue your writing. I
Some genuinely fantastic weblog posts on this internet web site , thankyou for contribution.
I’m really loving the theme/design of your web internet site. Do you ever run into any browser compatibility troubles? A couple of of my weblog readers have complained about my website not working properly in Explorer but looks excellent in Chrome. Do you’ve got any ideas to assist fix this concern?
Some truly good and helpful information on this internet site, likewise I conceive the style holds outstanding capabilities.
Your grasp of this subject is wonderful. It actually touched base to me and I am glad I discovered this material. Thank you extremely a lot.
This web-site can be a walk-through rather than the details you wished about it and didn
I like you weblog (desole, je suis francais, je parle mal anglais)
Currently actually do not stop eating because there is however the decision which you will transform into. Function from your home us rrs often a fad for that who wants to earn dollars but nonetheless enough time requires most substantial occasions making use of children and kids goes for as the modern habit. attract abundance
i would have to make a lot more christmas cards becuase next month is december already-
Wow! Thank you! I always wanted to write on my website something like that. Can I contain a portion of your post to my site?
Totally pent topic matter, appreciate it for selective info .
復興航空空難其實是制度殺人？ – 新公民議會
[url=http://www.g830k8yd63rc42j9m78f925tysuxyh43s.org/]uowjwxigr[/url]
owjwxigr http://www.g830k8yd63rc42j9m78f925tysuxyh43s.org/
aowjwxigr
You got a really useful weblog. I have been here reading for about an hour. I’m a newbie and your success is very a lot an inspiration for me.
You truly make it seem so easy together with your presentation but I find this matter to be actually something which I believe I would never comprehend. It seems too complex and extremely broad for me. I’m looking forward for your next post, I will try to get the hang of it! xrumer
for but another fantastic informative post, I
Thank you for the sensible critique. Me & my cousin were just preparing to do some research on this. We grabbed a book from our region library but I think I learned a lot more from this post. I’m really glad to see such fantastic info being shared freely out there
I do not even know how I finished up proper here, nevertheless I believed this publish was good. I do not realize who you
Very well written information. It will be valuable to anyone who employess it, including me. Keep performing what you might be performing – for confident i will have a look at a lot more posts.
Very good – I need to certainly pronounce, impressed with your site. I had no trouble navigating by way of all tabs and related information ended up being truly simple to do to access. I lately found what I hoped for before you know it at all. Quite unusual. Is likely to appreciate it for people who add forums or something, internet website theme . a tones way for your customer to communicate. Superb task.
Oh my goodness! an incredible article dude. Thank you Nonetheless I
I likewise conceive so , perfectly written post! .
I wanted to say Appreciate providing these details, youre performing a terrific job with the website…
dog grooming will be the specialty of my sister, she truly loves grooming every dog in our house**
It can be difficult to write about this topic. I believe you did an superb job though! Thanks for this!
I precisely desired to say thanks once again. I am not sure what I could possibly have tried in the absence of those suggestions contributed by you relating to such a subject. It had become a distressing condition in my view, even so , being able to view the well-written tactic you processed it produced me to weep over joy. Incredibly grateful for your guidance and believe you realize what an amazing job you
Thank you a whole lot for giving everybody an extraordinarily special possiblity to check ideas from here.
A thoughtful insight and ideas I will use on my weblog. You’ve got naturally spent a great deal of time on this. Effectively done!
There is noticeably big cash to comprehend this. I assume you’ve got created certain nice points in attributes also.
為何不具名？
1. 管理階層 有2種 a. 淘空公司 b. 賺錢給老闆看
搞飛機
2. 飛行員 a. 搞飛機 找新老闆投資買飛機 b. 搞空姐 c. 搞有錢女人
3. 機務 a. 一照闖天下英文都看懂了嗎b .搞飛機
4.空姐 嗨 別説了
三位資深機師同時關錯的機率有多小? 被"已知的"突發狀況嚇? 他們可都是飛行數千小時的老鳥，不是菜鳥。無人反對四秒關機，是早有原因?
二號機故障時高度是否已經很低? 一號機是否完全正常如"飛航專家"說返回機場? (只有一條跑道不是嗎?)根本就"飛回要檢修"了! 一直重開車是因為? 一架飛機的事故，絕對不會只有一兩個人的問題，是一整個機隊，甚至一整個公司的錯失。
在空中要是系統不可靠，身負重任的機師不會把乘客的命拿來賭啊! 降速找地方安全迫降是不是三位機師最確定，傷害最小的選擇?
往者英靈不遠，檢討時說話可否尊敬一點?
這篇文章我不覺得有貶低他們的意思
而對他們最尊敬的做法
就是確確實實、老老實實的把每一項細節錯誤通通檢討出來
而不是只會把尊重掛在嘴邊
否則他們不是白死了?
如果不肯真實的面對承認錯誤
類似的事件永遠還是會發生
另外我也可以告訴你…
古往今來所有的災難事件…
扣掉天然災害
人為因素都遠大於機械因素!!!
告訴我告訴我，你拿什麼告訴我？連個名字都不放你空口白話要說什麼？
你哪來的信心人為因素都遠大於機械因素!!!？？？更何況你怎麼分人為和機械？
下雨了害你摔車是人為還是機械？當然是人為，誰叫你下雨還不小心騎。
修車師傅沒把你的輪子鎖緊害你龍頭抖動摔車是人為還是機械？
當然是人為，因為師傅沒作好呀。
原廠叫你用一瓶500元的機油你偏偏用480的而且還不回原廠保養是人為還是機械？
當然是人為，誰叫你不回原廠。
你車子買回家半天前懸吊就斷了是人為還是機械？
當然是人為，要嘛就品管不嚴要嘛就設計不良。
哪一個機械不是人為的？除了天災都是人禍，哪有什麼機械、人為。
這篇是之前偶然間逛到的, 某位機長的blog….
http://cougarhsiung.pixnet.net/blog/post/367525235?fb_action_ids=1084273044932393&fb_action_types=og.likes